Supreme Court strikes down Tennessee residency requirement for liquor licenses

The Supreme Court on Wednesday struck down a Tennessee law that requir...

Posted: Jun 26, 2019 1:53 PM

The Supreme Court on Wednesday struck down a Tennessee law that requires individuals to live in the state for two years before obtaining a retail license to sell alcohol, a ruling that could give a boost to a large chain of liquor retailers in Tennessee and other states.

The 7-2 ruling is a loss for the Tennessee Wine & Spirit Retailers Association, a trade group of in state retailers, that argued that the law was legal under the 21st Amendment that bolstered a state's authority to regulate alcohol.

But critics, including a national chain, said the law amounted to discrimination against out-of-state residents in violation of principles of the commerce clause.

"Because Tennessee's 2 year residency requirement for retail license applicants blatantly favors the State's residents and has little relationship to public health and safety, it is unconstitutional," Justice Samuel Alito wrote in the majority opinion.

The case presented the high court with a rare opportunity to scrutinize the scope of the 21st Amendment that ended the Prohibition and gave states broad authority to regulate alcohol.

"Today's decision reinforces the Supreme Court's skepticism of state laws that tend to favor businesses owned by in-state residents over those owned by out-of-state individuals," said Steve Vladeck, CNN Supreme Court analyst and professor at the University of Texas School of Law.

"Although states remain free to give some benefits to their own residents, such as in-state tuition, the Court has increasingly worried about laws that discriminate between different commercial enterprises, an issue that, as this ruling suggests, does not tend to break down along partisan or ideological lines," Vladeck wrote.

Total Wine, a chain retailer in 23 states, sought to operate a store in Knoxville, Tennessee, and challenged the law that required individuals operating liquor stores to have lived in the state for two years. The license couldn't be renewed until the individual had been a resident for 10 years.

The Tennessee Wine & Spirits Retailers Association argued the law was justified under the 21st Amendment that was passed in part to give states broad authority to regulate alcohol. They argued the alcohol is unique, and not subject to regular commerce clause scrutiny.

The association's lawyers acknowledged states cannot discriminate against "out of state products" without running afoul of commerce clause principles, but said the law at issue applies to "in state" retailers.

They said the law was passed to increase the odds that liquor retailers will sell responsibly, and will make it harder to open a liquor store.

Total Wine's lawyer, Carter Phillips, argued the restrictions in the law are "by far the most onerous" with the "only conceivable purpose" of excluding non-resident owners from Tennessee's market and protecting in-state retailers from competition.

Phillips noted the state did not vigorously defend the law, so retailers had to step in.

He said the Supreme Court has "made clear that the Twenty-first Amendment was not intended to save laws that have no purpose other than protecting in-state businesses."

Thirty-four States and the District of Columbia supported Tennessee and argued it was "vital" for states to have the authority to regulate the sale of alcohol because they realize that "excessive alcohol consumption poses great risks to local health and safety and that the liquor market is uniquely susceptible to infiltration by criminal elements." Some 20 states have laws similar to Tennessee.

Indiana Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Confirmed Cases: 49575

Reported Deaths: 2739
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Marion11812690
Lake5337247
Elkhart343257
Allen2867133
St. Joseph202569
Cass16439
Hamilton1629101
Hendricks1439100
Johnson1306118
Porter78038
Tippecanoe7439
Clark67144
Madison66864
Vanderburgh6296
LaPorte59727
Bartholomew59245
Howard58258
Kosciusko5654
Marshall5217
Noble49128
LaGrange4829
Jackson4773
Delaware46052
Boone45944
Hancock45736
Shelby43425
Floyd39144
Morgan32831
Monroe31528
Grant30226
Montgomery29720
Henry29316
Dubois2906
Clinton2882
White26810
Decatur25532
Lawrence25125
Dearborn24723
Vigo2408
Warrick23229
Harrison21722
Greene19132
Miami1892
Jennings17912
Putnam1708
DeKalb1634
Scott1628
Daviess15017
Wayne1496
Perry1409
Orange13623
Steuben1332
Franklin1278
Jasper1252
Ripley1247
Wabash1152
Carroll1122
Fayette1037
Gibson1032
Newton9910
Whitley995
Starke963
Huntington822
Randolph804
Wells791
Jefferson782
Fulton731
Jay680
Washington671
Pulaski661
Knox650
Clay644
Rush603
Owen511
Adams491
Posey490
Benton480
Spencer461
Sullivan451
Brown421
Blackford392
Fountain332
Crawford320
Tipton311
Switzerland280
Parke240
Martin220
Ohio210
Vermillion170
Warren151
Union130
Pike110
Unassigned0193

Ohio Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Confirmed Cases: 61331

Reported Deaths: 3006
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Franklin11122439
Cuyahoga8518383
Hamilton6396206
Lucas2859304
Marion273739
Montgomery228335
Summit2269209
Pickaway220641
Mahoning1885239
Butler172147
Columbiana132460
Stark1171114
Lorain107368
Trumbull101474
Warren91825
Clark78410
Delaware64515
Fairfield61417
Tuscarawas59010
Belmont55822
Lake55122
Medina54832
Licking53612
Miami48631
Portage47759
Wood46151
Ashtabula43844
Clermont4367
Geauga41543
Wayne36752
Richland3595
Allen33841
Greene3009
Mercer29410
Erie26022
Darke25326
Holmes2524
Huron2342
Madison2069
Ottawa16124
Sandusky14215
Washington14220
Crawford1375
Ross1363
Putnam13315
Coshocton1323
Hardin12312
Morrow1201
Auglaize1094
Jefferson952
Muskingum921
Union921
Athens911
Monroe8917
Hancock841
Preble811
Hocking798
Lawrence790
Guernsey763
Shelby724
Williams722
Clinton700
Logan661
Fulton650
Ashland621
Wyandot615
Carroll603
Brown591
Scioto560
Defiance543
Knox531
Fayette510
Highland471
Champaign461
Van Wert430
Perry401
Seneca362
Henry320
Jackson270
Paulding270
Pike270
Adams241
Vinton222
Gallia201
Noble130
Harrison121
Meigs120
Morgan110
Unassigned00
Fort Wayne
Clear
70° wxIcon
Hi: 83° Lo: 66°
Feels Like: 70°
Angola
Clear
70° wxIcon
Hi: 78° Lo: 64°
Feels Like: 70°
Huntington
Clear
68° wxIcon
Hi: 78° Lo: 65°
Feels Like: 68°
Decatur
Clear
70° wxIcon
Hi: 81° Lo: 66°
Feels Like: 70°
Van Wert
Clear
70° wxIcon
Hi: 84° Lo: 65°
Feels Like: 70°
Breezy, Sunny Saturday
WFFT Radar
WFFT Temperatures
WFFT National

Community Events