Why American steel stocks plummeted in the past year, despite tariffs

A year's worth of tariffs have given a shot in the arm to the US steel industry — but not for their shareholders.Although the nation's steelmakers h...

Posted: May 21, 2019 1:30 PM

A year's worth of tariffs have given a shot in the arm to the US steel industry — but not for their shareholders.

Although the nation's steelmakers have benefited from reduced competition, their stocks have plummeted in the year since the Trump administration first signaled that tariffs were coming.

Shares of US Steel are down 70% since their March 2018 peak. Nucor, the largest steelmaker in the country, is down 25% over the same period.

The stocks' march lower will probably continue. Analysts have been cutting their price targets and recommendations on steel stocks this month, even before the Trump administration announced Friday that it would lift the tariffs against steel imports from Canada and Mexico, two major sources for imported steel.

Despite the tariffs, American steel companies' stock prices have tumbled for complex reasons.

Only a short-term gain

The tariffs provided some positives for the industry, such as a drop in low-priced imports and increased profits.

Steel customers worried about how much the tariffs would hurt their supply, so they went on a buying binge early in 2018. That drove up prices.

But last year's large rise in steel prices proved to be short-lived. The supply problems never actually took place. Customers started working off their stockpiles, which cut into overall purchases.

Slowdowns in the auto, energy and construction sector also hurt demand.

Flooding the zone with steel

The price spike early last year prompted steelmakers to increase output. Steel mills reopened, adding about 9,000 jobs to the industry. Existing mills also increased their output.

Production from domestic steel mills rose by 1 million tons in the first quarter of this year compared to the same period last year, before the tariffs took effect, according to the American Iron and Steel Institute, the industry trade group.

But they made way too much steel. The increased production far outpaced the drop in steel imports, which fell by only a half-million tons in the first quarter.

Prices for rolls of sheets of steel, a higher-priced product used in autos and appliances, has fallen 25% since it peaked at $925 a ton last July, according to UBS.

"We observe that supply exceeded demand ... over the last six months," said UBS analyst Andreas Bokkenheuser in a note to clients. "This explains the corresponding 25% price correction."

Spending money in the wrong places

More domestic capacity could be on the way. American steelmakers have announced plans to spend billions of dollars to increase capacity by 10 million tons annually since the tariffs were announced. Nucor alone has said it will spend more than $2 billion to add more than 2.6 million tons of capacity in the coming years.

The tariffs encouraged American steel companies to increase investment beyond simply increasing capacity. The steelmakers argue they needed to make the investment to be competitive for the future.

For example, US Steel announced this month that it is it is spending $1.2 billion on a new kind of steel mill that turns molten steel directly into thin sheets of steel on rolls. That technology would eliminate the step that steelmakers have used for more than a century to pour steel into thick slabs, let newly formed slabs cool and then reheat those slabs to press the steel into thin rolls. US Steel's plant would be the first in the country and one of only a few in the world.

"We're now pivoting from playing defense to offense," said CEO David Burritt.

But it's unclear how much of a future American steel has without continued tariffs or some other limits on cheap foreign steel, particularly from China.

"We're among the lowest-cost producers. We're extremely competitive if we're operating on a level playing field. But there is massive overcapacity of steel from China, multiples of US capacity, and it's heavily subsidized by the government. That's led to a very distorted global market for steel," said Kevin Dempsey, senior vice president of public policy for the AISI. "If we lifted the all the tariffs, I think we'd see another flood of imports."

Missing the buyback bonanza

Although companies are typically praised for plowing increased profits back in their core business, the additional capacity and investment is not how investors want the companies to spend their money, said Philip Gibbs, steel analyst for KeyBanc Capital Markets.

Because of that investment, steel companies did not initially participate in the stock buyback bonanza that followed the 2018 corporate tax cuts, which lifted so many American stocks. Most companies, like US Steel and Nucor, announced only modest buybacks that were dwarfed by their capital spending plans.

"They had expected the companies to give back to shareholders," Gibbs said. "Companies didn't really do it — they decided they'd spend billions on new assets, new capacity, multi-year investment programs. As a result, the stocks were punished,"

The outlook for US steelmakers looks much more difficult than it did when the tariffs were first imposed. The companies will probably struggle because of weaker demand, increased domestic capacity and less protectionist trade policies. That will probably increase pressure on domestic steelmakers for the rest of this year and into 2020, said Cowen steel analyst Tyler Kenyon, in a recent note to clients.

Indiana Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Confirmed Cases: 73287

Reported Deaths: 3036
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Marion15701725
Lake7496275
Elkhart480184
Allen3835163
St. Joseph342381
Hamilton2723104
Vanderburgh192213
Hendricks1871108
Cass17869
Johnson1741118
Porter129439
Clark120247
Tippecanoe118911
Madison94365
LaPorte89430
Howard88465
Kosciusko84712
Bartholomew78047
Marshall77422
Floyd77246
Monroe74630
Delaware71452
Dubois68712
Boone67246
Noble66329
Hancock64738
Vigo61910
Jackson5855
Warrick57930
LaGrange55710
Shelby54627
Grant52630
Dearborn49628
Morgan46734
Clinton4303
Henry37620
Wayne36810
White36110
Montgomery35221
Lawrence34227
Decatur33532
Harrison32723
Putnam2868
Miami2692
Scott26610
Daviess26420
Greene24634
Franklin24114
Jasper2342
DeKalb2304
Jennings22412
Gibson2214
Steuben2073
Ripley1997
Fayette1867
Carroll1852
Perry18412
Starke1777
Posey1700
Orange16924
Wabash1653
Fulton1642
Wells1622
Jefferson1602
Knox1510
Whitley1516
Washington1391
Tipton1379
Spencer1313
Huntington1223
Newton11810
Randolph1184
Clay1165
Sullivan1131
Adams962
Jay910
Owen871
Pulaski791
Rush764
Brown731
Fountain732
Blackford632
Ohio635
Benton610
Pike530
Parke511
Vermillion490
Switzerland460
Crawford440
Martin430
Union390
Warren221
Unassigned0202

Ohio Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Confirmed Cases: 99969

Reported Deaths: 3668
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Franklin18182523
Cuyahoga13414499
Hamilton9583255
Lucas5288323
Montgomery431894
Summit3523222
Marion292245
Butler289163
Mahoning2532255
Pickaway238342
Stark1813139
Warren176739
Lorain173678
Columbiana165660
Trumbull1518106
Fairfield136732
Delaware129219
Licking126049
Clark114214
Lake111138
Wood103058
Clermont92111
Medina91435
Miami83238
Tuscarawas78114
Portage75461
Allen73244
Greene68412
Belmont62126
Mercer60513
Richland60012
Erie57027
Ashtabula56246
Geauga55444
Wayne52958
Ross4684
Huron3955
Darke39329
Ottawa37726
Sandusky37316
Hancock3723
Athens3561
Madison35510
Holmes3276
Lawrence2790
Auglaize2506
Union2461
Muskingum2251
Jefferson2242
Scioto2241
Putnam20517
Seneca2043
Knox2037
Washington20222
Preble2012
Coshocton1926
Shelby1904
Crawford1745
Champaign1732
Morrow1682
Hardin16412
Clinton1626
Highland1561
Logan1522
Fulton1471
Wyandot1458
Ashland1433
Defiance1424
Williams1343
Brown1272
Perry1233
Guernsey1167
Henry1162
Hocking1169
Fayette1120
Carroll1115
Monroe9118
Pike760
Jackson740
Van Wert711
Paulding670
Gallia651
Adams592
Meigs380
Vinton312
Harrison261
Morgan250
Noble170
Unassigned00
Fort Wayne
Clear
72° wxIcon
Hi: 86° Lo: 68°
Feels Like: 72°
Angola
Clear
68° wxIcon
Hi: 86° Lo: 68°
Feels Like: 68°
Huntington
Scattered Clouds
67° wxIcon
Hi: 86° Lo: 68°
Feels Like: 67°
Decatur
68° wxIcon
Hi: 85° Lo: 69°
Feels Like: 68°
Van Wert
68° wxIcon
Hi: 83° Lo: 68°
Feels Like: 68°
Storms return for Monday
WFFT Radar
WFFT Temperatures
WFFT National

Community Events