An Ohio city will vote on whether Lake Erie has the same rights as a person

A beachgoer and her dog pause along the Lake Erie shore. Voters in Toledo, Ohio, will decide next week whether to give Lake Erie the kind of rights usually granted to a person.
A beachgoer and her dog pause along the Lake Erie shore. Voters in Toledo, Ohio, will decide next week whether to give Lake Erie the kind of rights usually granted to a person.

Voters in Toledo, Ohio, will decide next week whether to give Lake Erie the kind of rights usually granted to a person.The Lake Erie Bill of Rights, a...

Posted: Feb 21, 2019 10:00 AM

Voters in Toledo, Ohio, will decide next week whether to give Lake Erie the kind of rights usually granted to a person.

The Lake Erie Bill of Rights, a ballot initiative in Tuesday's special election, would establish "irrevocable rights for the Lake Erie Ecosystem to exist, flourish and naturally evolve" and "a right to a healthy environment for the residents of Toledo."

Opponents say the law could cost the region jobs and have vowed to fight it in court, should voters approve it.

Residents pushed to get the issue on the ballot amid anger over Toledo's 2014 water crisis, during which city officials told residents of Ohio's fourth-largest city not to touch their tap water. Following an algae bloom in Lake Erie, federal experts found a toxin in the city's drinking water, potentially making it unsafe for human contact.

Concerned citizens later sought legal recourse against polluters they believe drove the algae bloom but hit a wall, said Thomas Linzey, who leads the Community Environmental Legal Defense Fund, dubbed CELDF.

"These folks kept calling the cavalry, and the cavalry never came," he told CNN, adding that the ballot measure "comes from a frustration over a lack of protections in state and federal law."

Can lakes have rights?

"Basically, Lake Erie is dying, and no one is helping," Linzey said. "And this is the first time this type of law has been applied to this type of ecosystem."

Linzey, who co-founded CELDF in 1995, has dedicated much of his career to advancing new legal arguments aimed at the idea that the natural environment can have rights.

"We're waking up as Western civilization," he said, referencing Native American traditions that afforded great reverence to the natural environment.

Linzey's organization has worked with lawmakers around the world, notching successes in Bolivia, India, New Zealand and Ecuador, which in 2008 recognized rights of nature in its Constitution, he said.

In the United States, the group has worked with communities from Youngstown, Ohio, to Spokane, Washington, on similar "rights of nature" initiatives, though they haven't always survived court challenges.

The Ohio Supreme Court last month gave its blessing to Toledo's ballot initiative, setting the stage for next week's vote and possibly signaling a breakthrough opportunity for Linzey and his organization.

"If (the initiative) wins, it begins a conversation on who speaks for the lake," he said.

Not everyone is cheering

The measure, though, has its critics. Toledo City Council President Matt Cherry told CNN he's "100% against" the Lake Erie Bill of Rights, which he said "immediately will go into litigation if it passes."

The legislation would "deter industries from coming to Toledo," possibly costing the region jobs, Cherry said. The city also could end up spending taxpayer dollars to defend the law in court, he said.

Meantime, Toledo "has already done a lot" in response to the city's 2014 water crisis, including spending "almost $1 billion" on taxpayer-funded upgrades to its water treatment plants, Cherry said.

While organizers of the Lake Erie Bill of Rights have a legitimate gripe with the commercial animal-feeding operations that feed into Lake Erie tributaries, Cherry said, those conflicts have nothing to do with Toledo and should be taken up at the state or federal level.

Indiana Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Confirmed Cases: 114236

Reported Deaths: 3548
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Marion21067764
Lake10397321
Elkhart6477109
St. Joseph6312105
Allen6113201
Hamilton4803109
Vanderburgh353630
Hendricks2694123
Monroe253136
Tippecanoe234713
Johnson2291123
Clark218756
Porter210546
Cass19399
Delaware191861
Vigo180324
Madison161975
LaPorte140540
Floyd135161
Howard129263
Warrick123436
Kosciusko121117
Bartholomew115557
Marshall99724
Dubois96418
Boone96046
Hancock91743
Grant90334
Noble90032
Henry79326
Wayne75114
Jackson7469
Morgan70938
Shelby66829
Daviess65828
Dearborn64728
LaGrange63411
Clinton59514
Harrison56624
Putnam54211
Knox5139
Lawrence51028
Montgomery50721
Gibson4964
White48314
DeKalb46811
Decatur45839
Miami4313
Greene42235
Fayette41913
Jasper3902
Steuben3787
Scott36711
Sullivan33312
Posey3160
Jennings31212
Franklin30325
Clay2995
Orange28824
Ripley2878
Carroll27313
Wabash2638
Washington2631
Whitley2617
Starke2597
Adams2553
Wells2513
Jefferson2473
Fulton2352
Spencer2283
Huntington2253
Tipton22122
Perry21613
Randolph2117
Jay1760
Newton17211
Owen1681
Martin1640
Rush1544
Pike1431
Vermillion1270
Fountain1202
Pulaski1161
Blackford1143
Brown1043
Crawford1040
Parke972
Benton880
Ohio787
Union780
Switzerland690
Warren391
Unassigned0226

Ohio Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Confirmed Cases: 147744

Reported Deaths: 4715
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Franklin26545606
Cuyahoga17327656
Hamilton12953315
Montgomery7667157
Lucas7230364
Butler5838110
Summit5237252
Marion308347
Mahoning3030281
Warren300249
Stark2817170
Pickaway264444
Lorain229586
Delaware221620
Fairfield206752
Columbiana192480
Licking189863
Trumbull1876132
Wood180472
Clark177740
Clermont167923
Lake160850
Medina145139
Greene142032
Allen140869
Miami140751
Portage111666
Mercer110118
Erie93246
Tuscarawas92820
Wayne91967
Ross86823
Richland83919
Madison80212
Darke78442
Belmont71827
Geauga71348
Hancock68610
Ashtabula65548
Athens6532
Lawrence64122
Shelby61010
Auglaize5859
Putnam57923
Sandusky55820
Huron5427
Union5152
Scioto4896
Ottawa46930
Seneca46414
Preble43015
Muskingum3922
Holmes3857
Jefferson3354
Logan3083
Henry30613
Champaign3023
Perry2939
Defiance28811
Clinton28613
Brown2842
Knox28215
Washington25823
Morrow2572
Hardin25213
Jackson2466
Fulton2411
Ashland2364
Coshocton23311
Crawford2316
Fayette2286
Highland2223
Wyandot20812
Williams2063
Gallia18913
Pike1790
Meigs17410
Guernsey1678
Hocking1619
Carroll1527
Adams1264
Van Wert1163
Monroe11018
Paulding1070
Harrison632
Morgan470
Vinton473
Noble280
Unassigned00
Fort Wayne
Clear
72° wxIcon
Hi: 79° Lo: 56°
Feels Like: 72°
Angola
Clear
72° wxIcon
Hi: 80° Lo: 56°
Feels Like: 72°
Huntington
Clear
71° wxIcon
Hi: 78° Lo: 57°
Feels Like: 71°
Decatur
Clear
72° wxIcon
Hi: 79° Lo: 56°
Feels Like: 72°
Van Wert
Clear
72° wxIcon
Hi: 79° Lo: 55°
Feels Like: 72°
Sunny, Pleasant Friday
WFFT Radar
WFFT Temperatures
WFFT National

Community Events