Why the Jussie Smollett case warranted skepticism from the very start

With police sources saying that Jussie Smollett may have orchestrated his own attack, Brian Stelter talks with Kmele Foster and Liz Plank about whether news outlets were skeptical enough about the case from day one.

Posted: Feb 18, 2019 10:50 AM


A version of this article first appeared in the "Reliable Sources" newsletter. You can sign up for free right here.

The Jussie Smollett case reminds me of a scene in the Broadway production of "Network."

"Here is the truth," Bryan Cranston's character Howard Beale says in a monologue. "The real truth, the thing we must be most afraid of is the destructive power of absolute beliefs -- that we can know anything conclusively, absolutely -- whether we are compelled to it by anger, fear, righteousness, injustice, indignation."

"As soon as you have ossified that belief," he adds, "as soon as you start believing in the absolute, you stop believing in human beings, as mad and tragic as they are... in all their complexity, their otherness, their intractable reality... The only commitment any of us can have is to other people."

Some people absolutely believed Smollett when he said he was assaulted by two men in Chicago last month.

Now -- with police sources telling CNN and other outlets that new evidence suggests Smollett orchestrated the attack -- they are revisiting and revising assumptions about the case.

But the allegations merited skepticism from the very start.

Commentator Kmele Foster put it this way on "Reliable Sources" on Sunday: "Two in the morning, almost the coldest night of the year, you were attacked and someone conveniently had a rope? My heart goes out to anyone who gets attacked, but it's totally appropriate to exercise a bit of skepticism and to exercise a bit of patience in waiting for the facts to develop around this story."

Here are the latest developments in the case...

Smollett's camp still says he is a victim

On Saturday night Smollett's attorneys responded to the new reporting by reiterating that he was a "victim of a hate crime." They said he did not play a role in the attack.

Smollett himself has not commented publicly since his interview with ABC last week.

The Chicago PD wants to speak with him again

Chicago police detectives have been wanting to follow up with Smollett since Friday night. "We need to speak to him now," a police spokesman told me on Saturday, to corroborate info from the two men who were persons of interest — both of whom are now cooperating in the case.

Per spokesman Anthony Guglielmi's most recent tweet on Sunday evening, they're still waiting to speak with Smollett. The ball is in Smollett's legal team's court.

What Fox is saying

Nothing.

In the immediate aftermath of the alleged attack, Fox — which makes and airs "Empire" — took Smollett's word for it and said the company "stands united" against any act of violence and hate.

A few days ago, amid rumors that Smollett might have concocted the attack because he was concerned about being written off "Empire," Fox said that was ridiculous: "He remains a core player on this very successful series and we continue to stand behind him." Over the weekend, Fox representatives said the company had no new comment.

Why this story is so complicated

When Smollett reported the alleged crime to the police, many people figured Smollett was telling the truth. The allegation immediately had political significance because TMZ reported that Smollett said the attackers called Chicago "MAGA country."

Was there a rush to judgment in some quarters? Yes. Did some liberal celebrities and Democratic politicians issue statements that weren't supported by the facts? Yes. Did some Trump supporters feel insulted by the news coverage of the case? Yes.

But at the same time: Was it newsworthy when the police opened an investigation into Smollett's accusation? Yes. Did high-quality news organizations approach the case with caution? Yes. Did local and national news organizations poke holes in his "hate crime" account? Yes.

Kmele Foster and Liz Plank discussed the rush to judgment issue on Sunday's "Reliable Sources." Foster urged skepticism on the part of the press -- he said some people had doubts about Smollett's story early on, but "were afraid to raise the questions because of the intersectional nature of this particular accusation," afraid their motives would be challenged.

Plank was more concerned about the downstream effects of a potential hate-crime hoax. "The fact that one robbery was faked does not mean robbery is not a problem," she said. "The fact that there is one false rape accusation does not mean that there's no rape. We have to cover these issues as trends and as patterns." Bill Carter also joined in... Watch part one and part two of the segment here...

How the narrative is changing

The national outrage about Smollett's apparent suffering "was fueled in part by celebrities who spoke out loud and strong on social media," the AP's Lindsey Bahr pointed out in this story.

But the outrage "has now been replaced by surprise, doubt and bafflement," she wrote. And the authorities still aren't commenting, so this case is still a mystery.

Indiana Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Confirmed Cases: 112626

Reported Deaths: 3520
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Marion20832759
Lake10292318
Elkhart6415109
St. Joseph6156102
Allen6029200
Hamilton4724109
Vanderburgh344530
Hendricks2673122
Monroe247436
Tippecanoe226913
Johnson2268123
Clark215056
Porter207845
Cass19329
Delaware188261
Vigo178123
Madison159575
LaPorte137739
Floyd131461
Howard128563
Kosciusko120217
Warrick119936
Bartholomew115357
Marshall98924
Dubois95418
Boone95146
Hancock91143
Grant89133
Noble89132
Henry77024
Wayne74414
Jackson7409
Morgan70038
Shelby66529
Daviess64427
Dearborn63228
LaGrange63111
Clinton59212
Harrison56024
Putnam53710
Lawrence50528
Montgomery50521
Knox5019
Gibson4854
White48114
DeKalb45611
Decatur45439
Miami4263
Fayette41813
Greene41835
Jasper3862
Steuben3707
Scott35610
Sullivan33012
Jennings31212
Posey3060
Franklin29925
Clay2935
Orange28524
Ripley2838
Carroll27013
Wabash2618
Washington2611
Starke2537
Whitley2526
Wells2482
Adams2453
Jefferson2443
Fulton2342
Huntington2223
Tipton21722
Spencer2153
Perry21413
Randolph2087
Jay1730
Newton17111
Owen1651
Martin1640
Rush1524
Pike1401
Vermillion1260
Fountain1182
Pulaski1151
Blackford1133
Crawford1030
Brown1023
Parke941
Benton880
Union770
Ohio767
Switzerland700
Warren391
Unassigned0225

Ohio Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Confirmed Cases: 145850

Reported Deaths: 4635
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Franklin26242603
Cuyahoga17196644
Hamilton12850309
Montgomery7583152
Lucas7187358
Butler5727102
Summit5172249
Marion307247
Mahoning3002279
Warren294748
Stark2771168
Pickaway263444
Lorain227786
Delaware216620
Fairfield203850
Columbiana192180
Licking187562
Trumbull1852131
Clark175938
Wood173772
Clermont165520
Lake158649
Medina143939
Allen138869
Miami138049
Greene137632
Portage109466
Mercer107717
Tuscarawas91620
Erie91244
Wayne90866
Ross86123
Richland80819
Madison78712
Darke76839
Belmont71227
Geauga70547
Hancock67410
Ashtabula65148
Athens6292
Lawrence61618
Shelby5909
Auglaize5709
Putnam55823
Sandusky55520
Huron5337
Union5002
Scioto4746
Ottawa46630
Seneca45314
Preble42213
Muskingum3802
Holmes3777
Jefferson3284
Logan3013
Henry30012
Champaign2943
Perry2889
Defiance28710
Clinton28213
Brown2812
Knox28015
Morrow2522
Washington25123
Hardin25013
Fulton2371
Jackson2344
Coshocton23111
Crawford2276
Fayette2266
Ashland2244
Highland2203
Wyandot20212
Williams2013
Gallia18612
Meigs17210
Pike1670
Hocking1619
Guernsey1578
Carroll1517
Adams1234
Van Wert1143
Monroe10918
Paulding1050
Harrison622
Morgan470
Vinton453
Noble270
Unassigned00
Fort Wayne
Clear
57° wxIcon
Hi: 78° Lo: 50°
Feels Like: 57°
Angola
Broken Clouds
52° wxIcon
Hi: 78° Lo: 51°
Feels Like: 52°
Huntington
Clear
52° wxIcon
Hi: 77° Lo: 50°
Feels Like: 52°
Decatur
Clear
57° wxIcon
Hi: 78° Lo: 50°
Feels Like: 57°
Van Wert
Clear
57° wxIcon
Hi: 78° Lo: 50°
Feels Like: 57°
Mostly Sunny Thursday
WFFT Radar
WFFT Temperatures
WFFT National

Community Events