In the cavernous sanctuary of the National Cathedral on Wednesday, President Donald Trump came face-to-face for the first time with his four living predecessors, an encounter occasioned only by a loss to the most exclusive club in American politics -- indeed, in the world.
Trump's election, which came after he demeaned and humiliated the family members of three ex-presidents and made racist insinuations about his predecessor, has shaken the traditional fraternity of past and current commanders in chief. He had, until now, avoided any encounters with the collected group, and hadn't spoken at all with three of them. He has neither consulted them on issues nor avoided overt criticism of their presidencies, breaking tradition on matters large and small.
2016 Presidential election
Deaths and fatalities
Elections (by type)
Elections and campaigns
George W. Bush
Government and public administration
Government bodies and offices
Political Figures - US
US Federal elections
US federal government
US Presidential elections
For the time he was inside the cathedral on Wednesday, those hurtful slights remained unmentioned, at least out loud. But few watching the men's interaction -- or lack thereof -- would believe a new camaraderie is emerging between Trump and the men who served before him.
As he was shown to his seat, Trump reached over his wife to shake President Barack Obama's hand, who greeted him with a nod. It was their first interaction since Inauguration Day almost two years ago, and it lasted mere seconds.
Michelle Obama, who wrote in her memoir this year that Trump's birther conspiracy endangered her daughters, offered the President a quick "good morning" before turning away and looking straight ahead.
And that was it. Trump did not shake hands with the Clintons or the Carters, seated several seats away, though first lady Melania Trump extended a hand to greet President Bill Clinton, who smiled warmly.
The presidents club, by nature, is complicated by past rivalries and future legacies. Yet regardless of party, the members -- so far, all men -- are bound by their singular experience of serving in the Oval Office. It's impossible to know, at this stage of his presidency, what Trump's ultimate role in the club will be. But he enters the group carrying a long record of dismissive, vitriolic criticism extending well beyond partisan politics.
Club of competitors
The late President Bush was himself a testament to the bygones-be-bygones nature of a club that is composed of political competitors. After Bush's bruising loss to Clinton in 1992, the two men eventually teamed up to lead humanitarian efforts after a devastating tsunami in Asia.
Trump, who maintains grudges going back decades, has shown little interest in developing relationships with his predecessors during his first two years in office, according to those who have spoken with him. He has reached out to them sparingly, including a birthday phone call to the elder Bush two summers ago. When Trump selected Brett Kavanaugh as his Supreme Court nominee in July, he placed a call to George W. Bush, whom Kavanaugh had served in the West Wing as staff secretary. Later, the younger Bush phoned lawmakers to press for Kavanaugh's confirmation.
As George W. Bush entered the National Cathedral on Wednesday, he shook Trump's hand heartily. But his most obvious act of warmth was reserved for Michelle Obama, to whom he handed a piece of candy -- returning the gesture she extended during Sen. John McCain's funeral in the same building three months ago.
Until Wednesday, Trump had not spoken to Obama since they parted ways at the East Front of the US Capitol two Januaries ago, where the new President waved off the last as Obama left Washington in a military helicopter. The two men were separated by only one seat at the cathedral, filled by first lady Melania Trump.
Neither had he spoken to Clinton or his 2016 rival, Hillary Clinton, who were seated a few feet away. That didn't change on Wednesday; the President wasn't seen speaking at all with the 42nd President or his wife.
Neither did he speak with President Jimmy Carter, though earlier in his term Trump did take notice when the former president suggested the media don't treat him fairly, and praised the Democrat in private to his friends.
The relative silence is a break from how presidents have usually interacted with the men who've held the job in the past. Acrimony, even after fiercely contested elections, is usually cast aside or at least aired only in private. Most presidents occasionally consult in some capacity with one or more of their predecessors, usually in private.
That was on display before Trump arrived on Wednesday, as the Obamas, Clintons and Carters mingled easily among both their political allies and rivals.
Bush family and Trump
The tensions between the Bush family and Trump, which were a recurring theme of the 2016 Republican primary after Trump belittled GOP rival Jeb Bush, roared back into public view after Barbara Bush died in April. She had been highly critical of Trump, saying at one point: "He's said terrible things about women, terrible things about the military. I don't understand why people are for him."
And she made clear she did not want him at her funeral.
But shortly after her body was laid to rest, when it seemed as though her husband's health was failing and his death was imminent, the Bush family reached out to the White House to inform Trump the state funeral for Bush would be different. The former president wanted the current occupant of the office to attend, two people familiar with the conversations said.
It was less of an olive branch than a sign of the former president's penchant for protocol, a Bush family friend said. The decision also meant that the week of Bush's death would be devoted to a celebration of his life and service, not a messy public feud with Trump.
"This is a chance for the country to remember -- and learn again -- about 41," a Bush family friend said.
Trump, who campaigned as an outsider and has grown accustomed to not being welcomed into several elite clubs and social circles in New York, has indicated that he appreciates the gesture.
"The elegance and precision of the last two days have been remarkable!" Trump tweeted.
He has maintained a gracious and reverent demeanor this week, including traveling late Monday to view Bush's casket lying in state in the Capitol Rotunda and paying a call to Blair House, where the Bush family is staying, on Tuesday. Former first lady Laura Bush and Melania Trump, who have maintained warmer ties than their husbands, toured the White House Christmas decorations.
"In this case, I think that it is important to show the continuity between presidents, that Donald Trump isn't just an individual, he represents the institution of the presidency, which 41 held so dear," said Douglas Brinkley, a CNN presidential historian and professor at Rice University.
"So it's very appropriate that he's there. My concern is strange tweets in the middle of it, because of all the Mueller investigation things coming out. He very well may be behaved during the ceremony and 15 minutes later be writing strange things," Brinkley added.
Only five months ago, the President was mocking Bush's trademark "thousand points of light" philosophy of public service during a rally in Montana.
"What the hell is that?" Trump asked supporters in July. "Has anyone ever figured that one out? And it was put out by a Republican, wasn't it? I know one thing: Make America Great Again we understand."
He has bluntly said George W. Bush "lied" about the Iraq War -- hardly a controversial sentiment among many Democrats, which Trump was for much of his life -- but he took it a step further while campaigning in 2016.
"Excuse me, the World Trade Center," Trump said, a pointed reference to how the September 11, 2001, terrorist attacks took place on Bush's watch. Since taking office, Trump has privately derided the younger Bush as "genius" for entering the Iraq War.
Trump's most incendiary comments of all come through his inaccurate and racist questioning of Obama's American citizenship. In her bestselling memoir this year, Michelle Obama wrote: "Donald Trump, with his loud and reckless innuendos, was putting my family's safety at risk. And for this I'd never forgive him." The former first lady canceled book tour events in Europe this week to attend Bush's funeral.
In a 2011 interview with The New York Times' Maureen Dowd, George H.W. Bush summed up his view of Trump like this: "He's an ass."
Still, the presidents club is like family -- members have little say in who joins.
Indeed, the club runs more on tradition and the forging of personal relationships than on etched rules or guidelines. It's an exclusive gathering that primarily convenes to christen a presidential library or to bid farewell at a state funeral, though George W. Bush made a point of inviting all the former presidents, including his father, to meet Obama as he was entering office in 2009.
The services for Bush on Wednesday were the fourth state funeral at the soaring National Cathedral in Washington, with Gerald Ford's in 2007, Ronald Reagan's in 2004 and Dwight D. Eisenhower's in 1969.
Bush "planned his funeral memorial service right to have President Trump attend. But let's be honest -- there's nobody that wants to see President Trump at this memorial service that's going to be there," Brinkley said. "But he's going to be there. And what's going to be interesting -- people will be looking to see who comes up to him, how does everybody act."
"People will have to endure the fact that President Trump is there," Brinkley said. "But it's good that he's there."