Judge dismisses one count in Harvey Weinstein's criminal case

A New York judge dismissed count six of Harvey Weinstein's criminal indictment Thursday, which was a crimina...

Posted: Oct 12, 2018 10:39 AM
Updated: Oct 12, 2018 10:39 AM

A New York judge dismissed count six of Harvey Weinstein's criminal indictment Thursday, which was a criminal sexual act in the first degree.

The count stems from charges brought forth against the disgraced movie producer in May and July by the Manhattan District Attorney's Office.

Business figures

Harvey Weinstein

Crime, law enforcement and corrections

Criminal law

Law and legal system

Crimes against persons

Criminal offenses

Sex crimes

Sexual assault

Sexual misconduct

Society

A source familiar with the investigation told CNN at the time that the criminal sex act charge was from a case involving aspiring actress Lucia Evans, who alleged Weinstein forced her to perform oral sex on him in his Tribeca office in 2004. She first spoke out about the alleged incident to Ronan Farrow in the New Yorker last fall.

The reason that count was dropped today was due, in part, to a newly unsealed letter that prosecutor Joan Illuzzi-Orbon sent to defense counsel Benjamin Brafman in September.

It cites alleged inconsistencies in Evans' story.

Although the letter does not specifically name Evans, Brafman named her in court, and her attorney, Carrie Goldberg, spoke to reporters after the hearing ended. Goldberg said that the decision "does not invalidate the truth of her (client's) claims."

According to the letter, when Evans first met Weinstein at a restaurant in the summer of 2004, she says she was accompanied by a friend. That friend was interviewed by detective Nicholas DiGaudio in February of 2018.

The friend allegedly said during that interview that Evans told her she had engaged in consensual contact with Weinstein: oral sex in exchange for a job.

The friend also told the detective she was contacted by The New Yorker and only told them "something inappropriate happened."

According to the letter, Detective DiGaudio responded to the friend's claims by saying that, going forward, "less is more," and that the witness had no obligation to cooperate. He never went back to the DA with this information.

Evans' friend subsequently contacted the district attorney's office in August of 2018, after Weinstein was indicted, to reiterate that Evans had told her she willingly engaged with Weinstein.

Evans was again interviewed by the district attorney's office in August 2018. She stated she "never consented to any form of sex with the defendant," contradicting her friend's account.

The District Attorney's office additionally states in the letter that they interviewed Detective DiGaudio concerning the inconsistencies. He acknowledged speaking by phone with the friend and her attorney, along with failing to inform the DA's office of the important details of that discussion. DiGaudio also denied telling the friend she did not have to come forward and that "less is more."

The DA says they obtained a draft email from Evans to her now-husband recounting the incident with Weinstein. According to the letter, that account differs from what she told the DA. Evans says the inconsistencies come from her flawed memory, and that she never disclosed the details of the sexual assault to her husband.

Goldberg said the prosecution "jumped ship" and "ultimately she was caught between the middle of a feud between the NYPD and the DA's office."

Related: Harvey Weinstein is charged with rape and sex abuse in cases involving 2 women

Goldberg added that despite District Attorney Cy Vance not opposing the motion to dismiss the charge against Weinstein, her client's claims remain and this "does speak to a system desperate in need of reform."

"People always ask why don't sexual assault survivors come forward, this is why. Today is why," Goldberg said. Goldberg detailed how prosecutors used Evans for months and "put her through needless torture."

The attorney said her client will continue her fight in other venues.

"Victims are becoming warriors and this is just the beginning," she added.

Weinstein had previously pleaded not guilty to the six sex crimes he's been charged with in New York, including two counts of rape. The charges are based on claims from three accusers.

Benjamin Brafman, Weinstein's attorney, has filed a motion to dismiss the case and told reporters Thursday that he intends to refile that motion for the five remaining charges.

"What troubles me is that when you are vilified in the media, as has Mr. Weinstein, there is a rush to judgment, which is offensive to the concept of fairness and due process," Brafman said. "There is a rush to arrest, there is pressure to arrest, and what we see is that happened in this case."

Prosecutor Joan Illuzzi-Orbon told reporters she remains confident in the case against Weinstein.

"Nothing in this disclosure of count six impacts the strength of the case," Illuzzi-Orbontold said. "We are moving full steam ahead."

The next hearing in the case is scheduled for December 20.

Indiana Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Cases: 664446

Reported Deaths: 12663
CountyCasesDeaths
Marion909511650
Lake48568884
Allen36004640
Hamilton32182398
St. Joseph30166513
Elkhart25453419
Vanderburgh21300382
Tippecanoe20143203
Johnson16407361
Porter16042276
Hendricks15877300
Clark12018181
Madison11776319
Vigo11660231
Monroe10379163
Delaware9870179
LaPorte9802198
Howard9083199
Kosciusko8582111
Bartholomew7488147
Warrick7438151
Hancock7428133
Floyd7243170
Wayne6648192
Grant6446157
Boone610989
Morgan6106126
Dubois5925112
Dearborn549969
Cass547299
Marshall5439105
Henry542594
Noble510578
Jackson465167
Shelby461991
Lawrence4193113
Harrison402564
Gibson402083
Clinton396753
Montgomery389683
DeKalb387178
Knox357885
Miami357863
Whitley350237
Huntington347377
Steuben339555
Wabash332676
Putnam331260
Ripley327862
Adams324749
Jasper318143
White297952
Jefferson295874
Daviess285696
Fayette272156
Decatur271188
Greene262080
Posey261431
Wells258675
Scott251350
LaGrange241870
Clay241444
Randolph225676
Spencer218930
Jennings216344
Washington212827
Sullivan203639
Fountain202142
Starke189051
Owen183253
Fulton179837
Jay178528
Carroll176619
Perry173736
Orange171250
Rush165322
Vermillion161442
Franklin159635
Tipton148441
Parke140016
Pike128233
Blackford120727
Pulaski107344
Newton96632
Brown95140
Benton92213
Crawford91713
Martin80314
Warren75914
Switzerland7558
Union67510
Ohio54011
Unassigned0432

Ohio Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Cases: 974480

Reported Deaths: 16750
CountyCasesDeaths
Franklin1125851214
Cuyahoga964441832
Hamilton736841034
Montgomery47424903
Summit40474802
Butler35678505
Lucas35588685
Stark29495803
Warren22510271
Lorain22111414
Mahoning19532537
Lake18471318
Clermont18459201
Delaware16537116
Licking15037189
Fairfield14587180
Trumbull14381413
Greene13626218
Medina13448226
Clark12319248
Wood11604163
Portage11078164
Allen10804216
Richland10334183
Miami10048189
Muskingum8204112
Columbiana8160200
Pickaway8079107
Tuscarawas8063227
Marion8006125
Wayne7898193
Erie6925140
Ross6161128
Geauga6097136
Hancock6013116
Ashtabula5993152
Scioto597780
Lawrence527218
Union515237
Darke5040114
Belmont497659
Huron4838107
Jefferson4814107
Sandusky4785108
Seneca4709107
Washington470991
Athens465447
Mercer459180
Auglaize456480
Shelby442479
Knox4045101
Putnam400090
Madison394253
Ashland381381
Fulton381258
Defiance372983
Brown372244
Crawford359096
Logan356072
Preble353678
Clinton341152
Highland328649
Ottawa324869
Williams302962
Jackson290745
Champaign289249
Guernsey288444
Perry270447
Fayette269441
Morrow260934
Henry247058
Hardin246558
Holmes243493
Coshocton238054
Van Wert230154
Gallia223131
Adams217436
Pike216026
Wyandot211747
Hocking194754
Carroll181641
Paulding160530
Meigs135930
Noble129333
Monroe116927
Morgan101119
Harrison100724
Vinton76613
Unassigned00
Fort Wayne
Clear
45° wxIcon
Hi: 45° Lo: 21°
Feels Like: 41°
Angola
Clear
43° wxIcon
Hi: 43° Lo: 20°
Feels Like: 36°
Huntington
Clear
45° wxIcon
Hi: 45° Lo: 20°
Feels Like: 39°
Fort Wayne
Clear
45° wxIcon
Hi: 45° Lo: 22°
Feels Like: 41°
Lima
Partly Cloudy
43° wxIcon
Hi: 46° Lo: 21°
Feels Like: 36°
Seasonal Saturday
WFFT Radar
WFFT Temperatures
WFFT National

Community Events