Kickoff rule tied to fewer concussions in Ivy League football, new research says

A new football study has found that a small change in one area of the sport -- kickoff rules -- may lead to ...

Posted: Oct 2, 2018 12:39 PM
Updated: Oct 2, 2018 12:39 PM

A new football study has found that a small change in one area of the sport -- kickoff rules -- may lead to a significant reduction in concussion rates.

A research letter published Monday in the medical journal JAMA said that after the Ivy League athletic conference changed its rules in 2016 to move the kickoff and touchback lines in games, there was a reduction in the concussion rate among players.

Brain injuries

Concussions

Diseases and disorders

Football (American)

Head injuries

Health and medical

Ivy League

NCAA

Neurological disorders and injuries

Sports and recreation

Sports organizations and teams

Universities and colleges

Wounds and injuries

Public health

Specifically, the average annual concussion rate in the college conference was 10.93 per 1,000 plays during kickoff before the rule change. It dropped to 2.04 after, the researchers found.

"What that translates to is about a 69% reduction in the rate of concussion," said Douglas Wiebe, first author of the research letter and a professor of biostatistics and epidemiology at the University of Pennsylvania's Perelman School of Medicine.

In comparison, the researchers found that for other play types, the average annual concussion rate was 2.56 before the rule change and 1.18 after, which was not a significant difference.

"To see that rate of concussion went down that much, very strongly in kickoff returns relative to other types of plays over the same period, we think it's an example of a public health intervention that was part of a large collaboration between injury epidemiologists and coaches and athletic trainers," Wiebe said.

The kickoff return play poses a risk of concussion -- a type of traumatic brain injury caused by a blow to the head -- because it involves players running at speed toward each other over a long distance, the researchers noted.

In 2015, kickoffs accounted for 6% of all plays but 21% of concussions in the Ivy League conference, the researchers said, referencing data published in the journal Injury Prevention.

The next year, the rule change called for moving the kickoff line from the 35-yard line to the 40 and the touchback line from the 25-yard line to the 20.

Small change tied to significant reduction

For the study, researchers analyzed data from the Ivy League's concussion surveillance system, identifying concussions occurring during in-conference regular season games from 2013 through 2017.

The Ivy League itself includes eight schools: Princeton, Dartmouth, Yale, Columbia, Pennsylvania, Harvard, Brown and Cornell.

The researchers evaluated each concussion by what type of play caused it and when it occurred, whether before or after the 2016 rule change.

The rule change was introduced as an experiment, Wiebe said.

"They weren't sure what was going to happen, but they thought it had a chance to be protective," he said.

The research had some limitations, including that the kickoff rule changes were only in the Ivy League, and so the findings may not generalize beyond the conference.

Also in 2016, another new rule eliminated full-contact hitting in practices in an effort to reduce overall injury rates.

"This rule likely did not differentially affect activities during different types of plays during competitions and hence would not bias this analysis," the researchers wrote in the study.

The research was part of the Ivy League-Big Ten Epidemiology of Concussion Study, an ongoing initiative of the Big Ten-Ivy League Traumatic Brain Injury Research Collaboration to look at concussions across sports.

As part of that initiative, "something that was surprising -- not surprising but exciting for us -- is that we have enough data that we're really able to look at this outside of a case by case basis and that we're able to look at this over the course of several years after the rule was put in place," said Bernadette D'Alonzo, a co-author of the new research and a clinical research coordinator at the University of Pennsylvania's Center for Clinical Epidemiology and Biostatistics, and the Penn Injury Science Center.

'Preventing concussion is much easier than treating concussion'

The study was "well-done," and the findings "make sense," said Dr. John Leddy, a primary care sports medicine physician and clinical professor at the University at Buffalo in New York, who was not involved in the study.

"It shows just how powerful rule changes can be in preventing concussions," said Leddy, who is also medical director of the University at Buffalo Concussion Management Clinic.

"That's important because you're going to get concussions in football, but if you can develop rules that reduce the risk, then preventing concussion is much easier than treating concussion," he said.

He added that more research could help shed light on whether other rule changes in football have been or could be associated with reductions in concussion.

For instance, "what the Ivy League and other divisions in NCAA football have done is limit the amount of contact in practices, because some of the concussions occur during the practice week, not just in games," he said.

It's too early to attribute the fall in concussions seen in the new research to just one rule, said Joseph Clark, professor of neurology and rehabilitation medicine at the University of Cincinnati who was not involved in the new research letter.

He called the recent findings "a step in a positive direction" but added that more work needs to be done.

"Other research has shown similar falls in concussion rates even before the 2016 rule changes," he said. "Finding out what rule, policy, culture, practices, education, et cetera, will help mitigate concussions will take a bit more work than examining one rule change."

Indiana Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Confirmed Cases: 111505

Reported Deaths: 3506
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Marion20699758
Lake10217318
Elkhart6368109
St. Joseph604597
Allen5965200
Hamilton4676109
Vanderburgh334129
Hendricks2650122
Monroe240836
Johnson2257122
Tippecanoe221013
Clark211756
Porter205244
Cass19319
Delaware187061
Vigo176622
Madison157775
LaPorte136737
Floyd130361
Howard127563
Kosciusko119017
Bartholomew114957
Warrick114135
Marshall98524
Dubois94918
Boone94446
Hancock90542
Grant88233
Noble88132
Henry76324
Wayne73914
Jackson7349
Morgan69638
Shelby66529
Daviess64127
LaGrange63011
Dearborn62628
Clinton59112
Harrison56024
Putnam5329
Montgomery50521
Lawrence50328
Knox4869
White47914
Gibson4744
Decatur45339
DeKalb45011
Miami4243
Fayette41813
Greene41835
Jasper3822
Steuben3677
Scott35310
Sullivan32912
Jennings30912
Posey3020
Franklin29725
Clay2925
Orange28224
Ripley2788
Carroll27013
Wabash2638
Washington2581
Whitley2526
Starke2517
Wells2472
Adams2443
Jefferson2433
Fulton2352
Huntington2213
Spencer2194
Tipton21722
Perry20913
Randolph2067
Jay1700
Newton17011
Owen1641
Martin1620
Rush1514
Pike1411
Vermillion1260
Fountain1152
Pulaski1141
Blackford1132
Crawford1030
Brown1013
Parke932
Benton880
Union770
Ohio767
Switzerland680
Warren401
Unassigned0225

Ohio Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Confirmed Cases: 144309

Reported Deaths: 4615
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Franklin25977603
Cuyahoga17092642
Hamilton12756308
Montgomery7501152
Lucas7119357
Butler563299
Summit5096249
Marion306347
Mahoning2991279
Warren291048
Stark2739168
Pickaway263344
Lorain226386
Delaware213520
Fairfield202050
Columbiana191980
Licking185762
Trumbull1848131
Clark172338
Wood170671
Clermont162620
Lake157649
Medina143038
Allen136767
Greene135228
Miami135049
Portage107466
Mercer105317
Tuscarawas91220
Wayne90166
Erie89944
Ross85622
Richland78419
Madison78012
Darke76039
Belmont70727
Geauga70347
Hancock6579
Ashtabula64348
Athens5972
Lawrence59418
Shelby5819
Auglaize5659
Sandusky55420
Putnam54123
Huron5237
Union4932
Ottawa46530
Scioto4646
Seneca43914
Preble42013
Holmes3717
Muskingum3712
Jefferson3184
Henry29712
Champaign2933
Logan2933
Perry2859
Defiance28110
Clinton27813
Knox27815
Brown2752
Hardin25013
Morrow2492
Washington24823
Fulton2341
Jackson2314
Coshocton23011
Fayette2256
Ashland2234
Highland2203
Crawford2186
Wyandot20112
Williams1983
Gallia18012
Meigs1729
Hocking1619
Pike1580
Guernsey1567
Carroll1507
Adams1214
Van Wert1113
Monroe10618
Paulding1010
Harrison611
Morgan470
Vinton453
Noble270
Unassigned00
Fort Wayne
Clear
73° wxIcon
Hi: 73° Lo: 42°
Feels Like: 73°
Angola
Clear
72° wxIcon
Hi: 72° Lo: 44°
Feels Like: 72°
Huntington
Clear
73° wxIcon
Hi: 74° Lo: 43°
Feels Like: 73°
Decatur
Clear
73° wxIcon
Hi: 73° Lo: 42°
Feels Like: 73°
Van Wert
Clear
73° wxIcon
Hi: 73° Lo: 41°
Feels Like: 73°
Warming up for Monday
WFFT Radar
WFFT Temperatures
WFFT National

Community Events