India's top court upholds marriage in 'love jihad' case

India's highest court has moved to strike down a ruling from a lower court that prevented a Hindu woman who had conve...

Posted: Apr 11, 2018 12:32 PM
Updated: Apr 11, 2018 12:32 PM

India's highest court has moved to strike down a ruling from a lower court that prevented a Hindu woman who had converted to Islam from living with her Muslim husband, in a landmark decision that upholds the right of inter-religious marriage.

The case had gained notoriety in India owing to allegations from the woman's family that she had been brainwashed by her husband as part of a broader Muslim plot, dubbed by right-wing Hindu nationalists as "love jihad."

Throughout the lengthy two-year court battle, 26-year-old Hadiya, who goes by one name only, consistently maintained that she acted on her own free will, despite claims from her father, Asokan K.M, that she was forced to convert to Islam by her husband.

"This was completely blown out of proportion," said Haris Beeran, the lawyer for the woman at the center of the case. "There was no element of 'love jihad' in this."

The Supreme Court's ruling, which was announced Monday, brings to an end her family's persistent attempts to nullify the marriage, with the three-judge panel stating that "the court has no right to annul marriage between consenting adults."

Referring directly to Hadiya's battle with her parents, which began in the southern state of Kerala, the judges ruled that the wishes of her family "cannot be allowed to curtail her fundamental rights," adding that the freedom to choose a spouse and convert to another religion was both a constitutional and a human right.

"Intimacies of marriage, including the choices which individuals make on whether or not to marry and on whom to marry, lie outside the control of the state. Courts as upholders of constitutional freedoms must safeguard these freedoms," said the ruling.

Radical nationalism on the rise

Hinduism is India's dominant religion, according to census data, with 828 million followers or 80.5% of the country's 1.3 billion population. Muslims make up 13% and Christians 2.3%.

Although interfaith marriages have long faced opposition within India, the phenomenon of "love jihad" has only recently gained popular currency, with advocates alleging that Muslim men are engaged in a politically motivated conspiracy to take over the country by converting Hindu women to Islam.

The popularizing of the term's usage, which dates back as far as the 1920s, has been linked to a broader rise in right-wing Hindu nationalism in the wake of the 2014 general election, which saw Prime Minister Narendra Modi's Hindu nationalist Bharatiya Janata Party sweep to power with an overwhelming majority.

According to a study sponsored by the US Commission on International Religious Freedom (USCIRF) released last year, hate crimes against Muslims, Dalits, and other marginalized groups have escalated since the election, with the report noting that India's "pluralistic tradition faces serious challenges in a number of its states."

The latest court ruling is unlikely to end debate around the issue of "love jihad," however. Speaking to CNN in the wake of the verdict Wednesday, Rakesh Sinha, honorary director of the India Policy Foundation, a think tank affiliated with the right-wing Hindu organization Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS), said that although the Supreme Court had overturned the previous judgment, "it doesn't mean that 'love jihad' is an imaginary thing."

"There are certain organizations which are radicalizing youth and using love and conspiratorial marriage as a tool to attract Hindu girls," Sinha added. "Their objective is to create disharmony and imbalance in society."

Lengthy court battle

Hadiya, who was born as Akhila Asokan, was raised by traditional Hindu parents in a small town in the southern Indian state of Kerala.

She left home for college some time prior to 2016, enrolling in a homeopathy school in a town in the neighboring state of Tamil Nadu. It was during this period, that according to previous court records, she converted to Islam, and changed her name to Hadiya.

Hadiya claimed it was only after her conversion that she decided to marry, finding her husband, Shafin Jahan, through a matrimonial website, those same court records show.

The two were married in December 2016. By then, Hadiya was already entangled in a court case with her father, who had pursued legal action in a bid to force his daughter to return home.

According to court documents, Hadiya's father alleged that his daughter told him "she had a plan to go to Syria for sheep rearing," and he was worried that she had been influenced by Islamic extremists.

Allegations of Jahan's connections to radical Islam have dogged the case from the outset.

The Supreme Court's ruling was made amid an ongoing investigation by India's National Investigation Agency (NIA), into Jahan's alleged links to radical Islamist groups.

The court's ruling on Monday allows the NIA investigation to continue with the caveat that it not touch on the couple's marriage. The Supreme Court initially ordered the NIA, a government counter terrorism agency, to start investigating in August 2017.

Last May, in ruling to annul Hadiya's marriage and place her in the permanent custody of her father, the Kerala high court said that "a girl aged 24 years is weak and vulnerable, capable of being exploited."

For about seven months, she remained at her parent's home, unable to finish her studies or to see her husband. In the meanwhile, her husband brought the case to the Supreme Court to appeal the decision.

The Supreme Court, in November 2017, issued a temporary order to allow Hadiya to resume her studies and freed her from her confinement in her parent's house.

As a result of the Supreme Court's ruling, Hadiya has been reunited with her husband and is continuing her studies in college, said Beeran, her lawyer.

Indiana Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Confirmed Cases: 49063

Reported Deaths: 2732
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Marion11760689
Lake5276246
Elkhart340255
Allen2835133
St. Joseph200169
Cass16429
Hamilton1608101
Hendricks1425100
Johnson1296118
Porter76738
Tippecanoe7359
Clark66844
Madison66764
Bartholomew59145
Vanderburgh5876
LaPorte58326
Howard58058
Kosciusko5624
Marshall5016
Noble48528
LaGrange4779
Jackson4733
Boone45443
Delaware45252
Hancock45236
Shelby43125
Floyd38444
Morgan32731
Monroe30928
Montgomery29720
Grant29626
Clinton2902
Dubois2886
Henry28216
White26610
Decatur25432
Lawrence24825
Dearborn23823
Vigo2388
Warrick22729
Harrison21622
Greene19032
Miami1862
Jennings17712
Putnam1708
DeKalb1634
Scott1628
Daviess14817
Wayne1436
Orange13623
Perry1359
Steuben1302
Franklin1268
Ripley1247
Jasper1232
Wabash1142
Carroll1102
Fayette1037
Newton9910
Gibson982
Whitley975
Starke943
Randolph804
Huntington782
Jefferson762
Wells751
Fulton721
Jay680
Washington671
Pulaski661
Knox640
Clay604
Rush583
Owen501
Adams491
Benton480
Posey450
Sullivan451
Spencer441
Brown421
Blackford392
Crawford320
Fountain322
Tipton311
Switzerland280
Parke240
Martin220
Ohio180
Vermillion140
Warren141
Union130
Pike110
Unassigned0193

Ohio Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Confirmed Cases: 60181

Reported Deaths: 2991
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Franklin10879439
Cuyahoga8277383
Hamilton6287206
Lucas2836303
Marion273639
Summit2241207
Pickaway220541
Montgomery220131
Mahoning1861239
Butler167447
Columbiana130960
Stark1156113
Lorain106468
Trumbull99774
Warren89525
Clark7809
Delaware61715
Fairfield60517
Tuscarawas58510
Belmont55522
Medina54332
Lake52920
Licking52012
Miami47531
Portage46159
Wood45251
Ashtabula43744
Clermont4317
Geauga41443
Wayne36552
Richland3515
Allen32841
Mercer2909
Greene2879
Darke25326
Erie25022
Holmes2453
Huron2282
Madison2029
Ottawa16024
Washington14020
Sandusky13814
Crawford1365
Putnam13215
Ross1323
Coshocton1302
Hardin12312
Morrow1181
Auglaize1074
Jefferson922
Union921
Monroe8917
Muskingum891
Hancock831
Preble801
Athens791
Hocking798
Guernsey763
Lawrence740
Williams722
Shelby704
Clinton680
Logan651
Fulton630
Ashland621
Carroll603
Wyandot605
Brown591
Scioto540
Defiance533
Knox531
Fayette480
Highland461
Champaign441
Van Wert420
Perry371
Seneca352
Henry320
Jackson260
Paulding260
Adams241
Pike240
Vinton222
Gallia201
Harrison121
Meigs120
Morgan110
Noble110
Unassigned00
Fort Wayne
Few Clouds
81° wxIcon
Hi: 92° Lo: 72°
Feels Like: 84°
Angola
Broken Clouds
73° wxIcon
Hi: 90° Lo: 71°
Feels Like: 73°
Huntington
Few Clouds
79° wxIcon
Hi: 90° Lo: 72°
Feels Like: 82°
Decatur
Clear
75° wxIcon
Hi: 91° Lo: 72°
Feels Like: 75°
Van Wert
Clear
75° wxIcon
Hi: 92° Lo: 72°
Feels Like: 75°
AM Storms, Slightly Cooler Friday
WFFT Radar
WFFT Temperatures
WFFT National

Community Events