STREAMING NOW: Watch Now

Here's why video game movies don't work

Often when popular video games like "Assassin's Creed" and "Prince of Persia" are turned into movies, audiences are disappointed. CNNMoney's Frank Pallotta explains why.

Posted: Mar 19, 2018 8:23 PM
Updated: Mar 19, 2018 8:26 PM

Warner Bros. and Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer tried to pull off one of the riskiest feats in Hollywood this weekend: a successful video game movie adaptation.

"Tomb Raider" took in about $23.5 million at the domestic box office in its opening weekend, according to Box Office Mojo.

That's a respectable haul, and the movie has performed better overseas. But it's not a smash hit: "Tomb Raider" placed second this weekend -- albeit behind Disney's "Black Panther," a worldwide sensation in its fifth week of release. (Warner Bros., like CNN, is owned by Time Warner.)

Reviews for the $94 million film, which stars Academy-Award winner Alicia Vikander as the video game archeologist Lara Croft, have been mixed.

Its first weekend of release in the United States was also only about half as lucrative as that of 2001's "Lara Croft: Tomb Raider," which starred Angelina Jolie as the titular hero.

It's not too surprising that "Tomb Raider" isn't on track to become a runaway hit. Video game films are notoriously difficult to get right.

"I don't think there's any studio executive in town that wants to see on the schedule that they have a video game adaptation pitch," said Jeff Bock, senior box office analyst at Exhibitor Relations. "It's just been a nightmare for studios."

Success stories in the genre are few. Bock pointed to 2001's "Lara Croft: Tomb Raider" attempt as an example.

That movie pulled in nearly $275 million worldwide, according to Box Office Mojo. But critics still weren't impressed. It holds a 20% rating on the review aggregation website Rotten Tomatoes.

It could have been worse. Nintendo fans might remember 1993's "Super Mario Bros.," a live-action movie about the company's plumber mascots. It made about $20 million and was panned by critics.

Related: 'Super Mario Bros.' animated movie in the works at Illumination Entertainment

More recent efforts have been mixed. "Max Payne," a 2008 action film that starred Mark Wahlberg as a vengeful police detective, was adapted from the eponymous video game. While it didn't completely tank — it made $85 million worldwide on its $35 million budget — critics derided the film as "convoluted and leaden."

"I do think it's a fool's errand to try and turn video games into movies," said the film's director, John Moore last Friday. "I don't know why Hollywood keeps doing it."

Moore, who also directed "Behind Enemy Lines" and "A Good Day to Die Hard," said "Max Payne" didn't click with audiences because it didn't add anything new to the franchise.

"The base material is inherently more cinematic. It's more dramatic. It digs deeper," he added. "What's the point of chasing a facsimile of a drama?"

There is one bright spot for the genre. If Americans don't like a movie based on a video game, there's a good chance it will find better luck overseas.

The fantasy epic "Warcraft," for example, made a paltry $47 million when it opened stateside two years ago. But its foreign total was about eight times that amount.

"Visuals can carry a film overseas," Bock said. "That's definitely been shown. Their appetite for this type of film is just much bigger."

Bock said he's still holding out hope for a bonafide mainstream hit in the United States. He suggested that studios try to emulate the Marvel Cinematic Universe, which helped turn the stigmatized superhero genre into a cultural phenomenon.

"The potential is so big for this to succeed that they have to keep trying," Bock said. "Once they crack it, it could turn into the next Marvel."

More said he was skeptical of that strategy. Comic books are still images, so the format leaves more room for interpretation. Video games don't have that limitation.

"The universe is established in the game. It's moving and it has action," he added. "It has everything you need."

Some film studios are already trying other ways to tap into the video game market that don't rely on straightforward adaptations.

For example, next month's monster film "Rampage" is inspired by the classic arcade game of the same name. But it tells a new story not taken directly from the game.

Other approaches have already shown signs of promise. The adventure comedy "Jumanji: Welcome to the Jungle" and Steven Spielberg's "Ready Player One" aren't based on any specific game titles. But the protagonists of both films are transported into video game worlds.

Related: Steven Spielberg's 'Ready Player One' to have world premiere at SXSW

"Jumanji" has earned $939 million worldwide since it was released last December. "Ready Player One" doesn't come out until later this month, but it has already gotten a lot of positive buzz.

That kind of inspirational approach might be the most effective one, said Jordan Crucchiola, an associate editor who has written about video game movies for New York Magazine's Vulture.

She suggested that films should take the "core elements" that make people like video games, and then add a story that fits on the big screen.

"You can take those fundamental elements and then blow a bigger story out," she said. "But make sure you're not fully abandoning the ethos of what you're adapting."

--CNNMoney's Frank Pallotta contributed to this report.

Indiana Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Cases: 605426

Reported Deaths: 9642
CountyCasesDeaths
Marion836221331
Lake45189680
Allen32646547
Hamilton29240315
St. Joseph27260380
Elkhart24354344
Vanderburgh19292248
Tippecanoe17905133
Johnson14974293
Porter14707168
Hendricks14295248
Madison10909220
Vigo10688179
Clark10581139
Monroe9338110
Delaware9089134
LaPorte9007162
Howard8177143
Kosciusko803182
Warrick668798
Hancock6639104
Bartholomew6443100
Floyd6377109
Wayne6106161
Grant5965115
Dubois554079
Boone549467
Morgan535595
Henry505564
Marshall502684
Cass482663
Dearborn476245
Noble471257
Jackson421947
Shelby413881
Lawrence389179
Clinton372043
Gibson369159
DeKalb345964
Harrison345644
Montgomery343354
Knox334339
Miami319844
Steuben313045
Whitley304526
Wabash301447
Adams299635
Ripley297545
Putnam294149
Huntington290659
Jasper288134
White272242
Daviess266774
Jefferson262538
Decatur246583
Fayette246348
Greene239262
Posey238128
Wells234050
LaGrange227662
Scott223439
Clay221832
Randolph212848
Jennings197736
Sullivan191133
Spencer190121
Washington183722
Fountain183127
Starke174843
Jay167022
Owen163637
Fulton163130
Orange157234
Carroll156415
Rush154418
Perry152727
Vermillion148634
Franklin147833
Tipton131832
Parke13038
Pike116226
Blackford110922
Pulaski96837
Newton90721
Brown87534
Benton86510
Crawford7929
Martin73013
Warren6777
Switzerland6575
Union6267
Ohio4867
Unassigned0375

Ohio Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Cases: 853982

Reported Deaths: 10599
CountyCasesDeaths
Franklin100550707
Cuyahoga849601082
Hamilton63509448
Montgomery42863417
Summit34586759
Lucas31151616
Butler30735231
Stark25598430
Warren19552140
Lorain18847223
Mahoning17215337
Lake15967154
Clermont15800111
Delaware1430578
Licking13130137
Trumbull12739313
Fairfield1269181
Greene11975136
Medina11504168
Clark10867265
Wood10289158
Allen9826126
Portage9213108
Miami911373
Richland9085117
Marion7437113
Tuscarawas7339181
Columbiana7286124
Pickaway721750
Wayne6987171
Muskingum693941
Erie6113127
Hancock549090
Ross546098
Scioto536364
Geauga503855
Darke467892
Ashtabula451073
Lawrence450154
Union447728
Sandusky434762
Mercer432488
Huron425441
Seneca424865
Auglaize421164
Shelby420522
Jefferson416769
Belmont412740
Washington385240
Athens37669
Putnam373575
Madison352129
Knox350222
Ashland342838
Fulton336543
Defiance328282
Crawford320573
Preble319137
Brown309121
Logan305532
Ottawa290143
Clinton287943
Williams277167
Highland273718
Jackson262445
Guernsey251325
Champaign249728
Fayette235130
Morrow23124
Perry228718
Holmes223874
Henry217349
Hardin211333
Coshocton204521
Van Wert201145
Gallia195426
Wyandot194651
Pike173917
Adams173015
Hocking171024
Carroll154216
Paulding143421
Noble120340
Meigs108024
Monroe100631
Harrison88421
Morgan82629
Vinton69513
Unassigned00
Fort Wayne
Cloudy
27° wxIcon
Hi: 31° Lo: 13°
Feels Like: 20°
Angola
Cloudy
23° wxIcon
Hi: 29° Lo: 12°
Feels Like: 23°
Huntington
Partly Cloudy
26° wxIcon
Hi: 30° Lo: 10°
Feels Like: 20°
Fort Wayne
Mostly Cloudy
27° wxIcon
Hi: 30° Lo: 13°
Feels Like: 20°
Lima
Cloudy
27° wxIcon
Hi: 32° Lo: 15°
Feels Like: 20°
Light Snow Sunday
WFFT Radar
WFFT Temperatures
WFFT National

Community Events