US Special Forces fighting ISIS in Syria

CNN gets an exclusive look into the war in Syria, with the US Special Forces. Nick Paton Walsh reports.

Posted: Feb 11, 2018 11:50 AM
Updated: Feb 11, 2018 11:50 AM

The legal battle over the detention of a US citizen accused of fighting for ISIS entered a significant new phase Friday as his attorneys submitted a filing that experts say could set up a showdown over the legal underpinning of today's war on terror.

The case of the unnamed American held as an enemy combatant in US military custody in Iraq has moved quietly over a series of procedural hurdles since he was turned over to US forces by an American-backed militia in Syria last September.

Judge says Pentagon must give notice if planning to transfer US detainee it alleges fought for ISIS

Now, after successfully inserting itself as a representative for "John Doe" and securing an order from a DC federal judge that would prevent his immediate transfer to a third country, the American Civil Liberties Union argued Friday that the US government acted illegally by detaining the man, potentially setting up a major test of the controversial post-9/11 Authorization for Use of Military Force.

"For nearly five months, the government has been detaining an American citizen without charge or trial, based on legal theories that no court has ever endorsed," the ACLU wrote in its filing.

At issue is whether the government can use the military force statute -- signed into law in the days following the terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001, and granting the US president the power to target those responsible for the attacks -- to detain an individual accused of fighting for ISIS.

Under the law, the president can use force against "those nations, organizations, or persons he determines planned, authorized, committed, or aided the terrorist attacks that occurred on September 11, 2001 or harbored such organizations or persons." The US has blamed al Qaeda for the attacks, and the group's late leader, Osama bin Laden, claimed responsibility for them.

"The answers to these questions are not clear, and if I were the government I would not want to risk litigating them," said Matthew Waxman, a professor at Columbia Law School and former Pentagon adviser on detainee issues.

The Authorization for Use of Military Force has been debated and reinterpreted over the years to match a changing enemy, but despite scrutiny it has avoided a significant challenge in Congress or the courts and remains the basis of the ongoing fight against ISIS, a group that originally called itself al Qaeda in Iraq.

Friday's court filing could represent the first serious challenge to the law.

In an interview before the ACLU filing, a Justice Department official said there were a "variety of possibilities" under which the government believes it can detain Doe, including the 2001 Authorization for Use of Military Force, a second such authorization signed in 2002 that provided the legal basis for the Iraq War and the president's war powers under Article 2 of the Constitution.

"We are very confident that we have a strong legal and factual basis to detain this person as an enemy combatant and are fully prepared to defend our authority to do that if that's what ends up being our decision about what the best outcome is for this guy," the official said.

The ACLU also provides in the filing the first public account of the detainee's story, writing that he "sought to understand firsthand and report about the conflict in Syria" and "was kidnapped and imprisoned by ISIS" and "tried numerous times to escape."

"Not even the government alleges that he ever took up arms against the United States or anyone else," the ACLU writes.

In its filing, the ACLU also rebuts the government's defense of the detention under the 2002 Authorization for Use of Military Force and the president's constitutional powers.

In a briefing schedule, the federal judge presiding in the case allows for the Justice Department to submit a further response to the ACLU's Friday filing.

The government could also bring criminal charges against Doe, a dual Saudi national, in US civilian court, or, as it has floated in previous hearings, attempt to transfer his custody to a third country.

If Judge Tanya Chutkan does, however, eventually rule in favor of the ACLU's petition against Doe's detention, she could open the door to a greater challenge to the use of the Authorization for Use of Military Force in the global war on terror, Waxman said.

"Detaining an American citizen fighting for ISIS in Syria puts this whole controversial argument about the AUMF before a court, because he has a right of habeas corpus to challenge his detention," Waxman said.

"If the government were to lose this argument, the detention case would call into question the entire legal framework of counter-ISIS operations," he said.

Indiana Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Confirmed Cases: 75862

Reported Deaths: 3069
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Marion16088730
Lake7688278
Elkhart492685
Allen4002163
St. Joseph357883
Hamilton2829104
Vanderburgh202213
Hendricks1927108
Cass18029
Johnson1789119
Porter135539
Clark128749
Tippecanoe123811
Madison100665
LaPorte93130
Howard91365
Kosciusko86812
Bartholomew81747
Floyd80948
Marshall79323
Monroe76631
Delaware74552
Dubois70812
Vigo69911
Noble68829
Boone68746
Hancock68339
Jackson5965
Warrick58830
Shelby56527
LaGrange56310
Grant52930
Dearborn51228
Morgan49334
Clinton4444
Henry40620
Wayne38510
White37611
Montgomery35921
Lawrence35227
Harrison34823
Decatur34132
Putnam3128
Daviess27720
Miami2772
Scott27210
Jasper2552
Greene25434
Franklin24615
DeKalb2384
Gibson2314
Jennings22712
Steuben2133
Ripley2138
Carroll1962
Fayette1947
Perry18713
Posey1790
Starke1787
Wells1742
Orange17424
Fulton1722
Wabash1703
Jefferson1672
Knox1610
Whitley1556
Tipton14312
Washington1421
Sullivan1381
Spencer1373
Clay1245
Huntington1243
Randolph1244
Newton12010
Adams1092
Owen991
Jay920
Rush854
Pulaski811
Fountain742
Brown741
Blackford652
Ohio656
Benton640
Pike590
Vermillion580
Switzerland530
Parke511
Martin480
Crawford450
Union410
Warren241
Unassigned0206

Ohio Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Confirmed Cases: 102826

Reported Deaths: 3708
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Franklin18697529
Cuyahoga13734505
Hamilton9766257
Lucas5448326
Montgomery443896
Summit3614223
Butler297663
Marion293545
Mahoning2595255
Pickaway239142
Stark1884140
Warren182139
Lorain181377
Columbiana167160
Trumbull1549108
Fairfield141632
Delaware134419
Licking131951
Clark117815
Lake113141
Wood106858
Clermont95311
Medina94535
Miami85839
Tuscarawas79314
Portage77163
Allen76946
Greene71812
Mercer63113
Belmont62326
Richland61412
Erie59728
Ashtabula57646
Geauga55944
Wayne54558
Ross4944
Darke40629
Huron4045
Madison40110
Ottawa39626
Sandusky39017
Hancock3893
Athens3602
Holmes3286
Lawrence3000
Auglaize2636
Union2601
Muskingum2431
Scioto2421
Jefferson2373
Seneca2283
Knox2127
Putnam21117
Shelby2104
Washington20922
Preble2072
Coshocton1967
Champaign1812
Morrow1762
Crawford1755
Hardin17012
Clinton1696
Highland1661
Logan1602
Ashland1543
Fulton1531
Wyandot1509
Defiance1504
Brown1462
Perry1403
Williams1363
Henry1222
Fayette1210
Guernsey1197
Hocking1189
Carroll1135
Monroe9418
Pike790
Jackson760
Van Wert732
Paulding700
Gallia701
Adams612
Meigs540
Vinton322
Morgan300
Harrison261
Noble160
Unassigned00
Fort Wayne
Clear
70° wxIcon
Hi: 82° Lo: 56°
Feels Like: 70°
Angola
Clear
63° wxIcon
Hi: 82° Lo: 56°
Feels Like: 63°
Huntington
Clear
68° wxIcon
Hi: 82° Lo: 57°
Feels Like: 68°
Decatur
Clear
68° wxIcon
Hi: 82° Lo: 56°
Feels Like: 68°
Van Wert
Clear
68° wxIcon
Hi: 83° Lo: 55°
Feels Like: 68°
Mostly Sunny Thursday
WFFT Radar
WFFT Temperatures
WFFT National

Community Events