4 red flags in the GOP tax bills

They're riddled with unintended consequences. They would create new loopholes.And they don't live up to the bi...

Posted: Dec 8, 2017 6:39 PM
Updated: Dec 8, 2017 6:39 PM

They're riddled with unintended consequences. They would create new loopholes.

And they don't live up to the big promises made by President Trump, Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin and Republican lawmakers.

Still, Republicans hope to merge the hastily passed House and Senate tax bills into one final piece of legislation before Christmas.

The accelerated pace has policy watchers worried.

"Historic tax reform efforts involved discussion drafts of legislative language, hearings on those specific proposals, extensive public comment periods. None of that is happening now," Lily Batchelder, a former chief tax counsel on the Senate Finance Committee, tweeted.

As tax experts, businesses and accountants continue to unpack what's in the bills, here are just four warning signs that the plan might not deliver what was promised or intended.

Red flag #1: Tax plan would not simplify the tax code

Republicans have been promising a simpler code. Some measures -- like a larger standard deduction -- could provide more simplicity.

But Senate Republicans decided at the last minute to reinstate the poster child for needless complexity: the Alternative Minimum Tax for individuals and corporations. It requires filers to calculate their tax burden twice -- once under one set of rules, and once under a different set of rules -- and pay whichever is highest.

Both the House and Senate bills also seek to lower the tax burden on so-called pass-through entities, which comprise the majority of U.S. businesses. Taxes on pass-throughs are paid directly by the owners and shareholders under the individual code. But the bills bar large law partnerships, accounting firms and other lucrative professional service firms from taking advantage of the new, lower pass-through rate.

At the same time, the bills would slash the corporate tax rate.

Consequently, many businesses -- after having an incentive for years to structure themselves as pass-throughs -- might suddenly have a reason to restructure as corporations.

"People are scrambling to figure out how lawyers and doctors may reorganize to get better rates," said CPA Meredith Tucker of Kaufman Rossin in Ft. Lauderdale, Fla.

It may not be a simple decision. Under the Senate bill, most individual and pass-through provisions sunset at the end of eight years. "We're going to go through all of this just to have it expire," Tucker said.

Another simplicity killer: The House bill proposes a complicated rule with an alternate workaround that would govern how much a business owner's income must be taxed as compensation, and how much can be taxed at the lower proposed business rate.

"The House bill is incredibly complex. They talk about making it simpler. But it's crazy complex," said John Arensmeyer, founder of the Small Business Majority, an advocacy group.

The upshot: H&R Block, which President Trump often said would be put out of business by his tax reform, can probably breathe easy.

Tax planning and accounting firms will be busy helping everyone figure out what the proposed changes mean to them, and how to plan around them if they find they'll be saddled with a higher bill.

Indeed, both bills would be a "bonanza" for tax planners, said Martin Sullivan, chief economist of Tax Analysts.

Red flag #2: Won't pay for itself

Republicans have consistently said their tax plan will pay for itself over time thanks to the economic growth it will spur. No nonpartisan analysis agrees with that. Instead, they show that the tax plan will add more than $1.4 trillion to deficits over a decade. The picture improves when growth potential is factored in but not by much. The Senate bill, for instance, would still add more than $1 trillion, according to the Joint Committee on Taxation.

What's more, since the bills' deficit-financed tax cuts would go into effect when the economy is experiencing its best growth in three years and the country's debt is already high and climbing, there's concern the cuts will spur inflation and diminish the government's ability to fight the next recession.

Red flag #3: Could saddle some corporations with a higher bill

The biggest unintended consequences so far, which lawmakers may try to fix in their final negotiations, are caused by the Senate bill keeping the corporate AMT.

GOP senators were trying to provide more revenue to pay for other last-minute changes. Yet in doing so, they effectively subverted the purpose of the corporate AMT, which is supposed to ensure that corporations don't take so many tax breaks that they pay no tax at all. Under the tax bill, the regular corporate rate is slashed to 20%, identical to the corporate AMT rate.

The last-minute switch also would render key tax incentives for corporations moot because they're not allowed to be taken under the AMT. One of them -- the research and development credit -- is intended to spur innovation.

The AMT change, combined with other provisions in the tax bill that curb valuable business tax breaks, means many corporations -- surprise! -- could face a tax hike. For instance, the CEO of coal company Murray Energy estimates his company would pay $60 million more a year.

Preserving the AMT also could undermine the structure of international tax reforms in the bills, according to a report by tax scholars, practitioners and analysts.

Red flag #4: Won't offer "big" tax cuts for the middle class

Trump and Republicans tout their tax plan as a boon for the middle class, not the wealthy.

Nonpartisan analyses show that middle-income households would in fact get tax cuts, on average, especially in the first half of the next decade. But the highest-income households on average would benefit more.

In the second half of the decade, tax cuts for middle-income households would greatly diminish on average, while those for the top 0.1% would increase, according to the Tax Policy Center.

Trump in particular has claimed several times that he would pay more under the GOP plan. That seems implausible given that so many provisions would directly benefit him and his family. One of the biggest is the lower tax burden on pass-through entities, which are how Trump's more than 500 businesses are structured.

The bills distinguish between types of income that qualify for lower tax rates and those that don't. But Trump is in luck, according to Steven Rosenthal, a senior fellow at the Tax Policy Center. Three staples of his income -- rents, royalties and licensing fees -- would qualify.

Indiana Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Confirmed Cases: 155246

Reported Deaths: 4065
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Marion25151785
Lake13570355
St. Joseph9145161
Elkhart8759135
Allen8129228
Hamilton6117113
Vanderburgh576760
Tippecanoe369515
Hendricks3268133
Monroe325738
Porter313649
Johnson3105128
Clark293961
Delaware293274
Vigo260538
Madison235093
Cass224022
LaPorte222858
Warrick192965
Kosciusko182625
Floyd179167
Howard162466
Bartholomew141558
Dubois138626
Marshall137426
Wayne126930
Henry125429
Grant125339
Boone122250
Hancock118245
Noble115933
Jackson112915
Dearborn94928
Morgan93740
Lawrence87436
Daviess87133
Gibson87111
Clinton84716
Shelby81730
LaGrange80115
Harrison76224
Knox75610
Putnam72816
Posey7146
DeKalb71011
Fayette66618
Steuben6278
Miami6095
Jasper5945
White58515
Montgomery58322
Greene53337
Scott51813
Decatur50439
Adams4837
Whitley4556
Clay4467
Ripley4418
Sullivan43714
Wells4288
Wabash4119
Starke4077
Orange40425
Huntington3905
Spencer3906
Washington3753
Franklin37225
Jennings36713
Fulton3523
Randolph3529
Jefferson3415
Pike33018
Carroll32513
Perry31014
Jay3056
Fountain2943
Tipton27523
Vermillion2411
Parke2323
Newton22511
Rush2154
Blackford2093
Owen2051
Martin1990
Crawford1581
Pulaski1521
Brown1393
Ohio1297
Benton1100
Union1100
Switzerland920
Warren781
Unassigned0234

Ohio Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Confirmed Cases: 190430

Reported Deaths: 5161
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Franklin31466640
Cuyahoga19706682
Hamilton16687343
Montgomery10377189
Lucas8285373
Butler8276129
Summit6689265
Warren420064
Stark3796181
Mahoning3709286
Marion338850
Pickaway301146
Delaware287227
Lorain272889
Fairfield264457
Licking257966
Wood249681
Clark249456
Clermont245938
Greene229242
Trumbull2270134
Allen213073
Columbiana212887
Miami199958
Lake193659
Medina185642
Portage162068
Mercer152128
Wayne140269
Ross139436
Richland132324
Tuscarawas129024
Athens12052
Erie115553
Darke114451
Madison105415
Hancock104725
Auglaize100616
Putnam97427
Lawrence93025
Shelby90914
Muskingum8884
Geauga85950
Scioto8599
Belmont78827
Union7583
Ashtabula72648
Sandusky71122
Huron70912
Preble62418
Holmes61710
Seneca60114
Ottawa58430
Fulton53711
Henry47317
Jefferson4694
Clinton46413
Defiance46013
Jackson4598
Crawford4528
Fayette4498
Highland4304
Logan4233
Ashland3986
Champaign3983
Knox38416
Brown3793
Perry36611
Washington35124
Morrow3442
Hardin33613
Williams3354
Coshocton32112
Guernsey3218
Pike3000
Wyandot29513
Gallia29113
Van Wert2633
Meigs21012
Adams2096
Paulding2012
Carroll2007
Hocking1979
Monroe16118
Noble1290
Vinton963
Harrison803
Morgan780
Unassigned00
Fort Wayne
Scattered Clouds
64° wxIcon
Hi: 75° Lo: 36°
Feels Like: 64°
Angola
Scattered Clouds
63° wxIcon
Hi: 71° Lo: 35°
Feels Like: 63°
Huntington
Scattered Clouds
66° wxIcon
Hi: 74° Lo: 38°
Feels Like: 66°
Decatur
Broken Clouds
61° wxIcon
Hi: 76° Lo: 37°
Feels Like: 61°
Van Wert
Scattered Clouds
61° wxIcon
Hi: 76° Lo: 37°
Feels Like: 61°
Friday Afternoon Showers & Thunderstorms
WFFT Radar
WFFT Temperatures
WFFT National

Community Events