Tax bill could make 'dark money' political contributions tax deductible

For the first time in American politics, anonymous "dark money" political donations could become tax-deductible. That...

Posted: Dec 8, 2017 4:41 PM
Updated: Dec 8, 2017 4:41 PM

For the first time in American politics, anonymous "dark money" political donations could become tax-deductible. That's if a provision currently being debated between House and Senate negotiators makes it into the final tax bill.

The issue at hand started with the "Johnson Amendment," named after then-Sen. Lyndon Johnson's 1954 measure that prohibits nonprofit groups who maintain tax-exempt status, including churches and charities, from directly participating in politics.

Congressional Republicans are negotiating a final tax reform bill

President Trump and Republicans want to end the "Johnson Amendment" blocking churches from operating directly in politics

The proposed change could be far more widespread, allowing donors to effectively deduct political donations for the first time

But efforts to repeal the Johnson Amendment have resulted in language that would ease political speech rules for all nonprofits. The results, critics say, could effectively let people deduct de-facto political donations and further hide those donations and spending from the public.

"This is taxpayer-subsidized "Citizens United,'" said Ian Vandewalker of the Brennan Center for Justice, referring to the 2010 landmark Supreme Court case that loosened campaign finance rules.

The House tax bill passed in November included a repeal of the Johnson Amendment, while the Senate did not. Currently, lawmakers are at work reconciling the two bills.

Opponents of the Johnson Amendment, including President Donald Trump and top evangelical leaders, say the law stifles religious freedom.

Speaking at the National Prayer Breakfast in February, Trump declared that he "will get rid of, and totally destroy, the Johnson Amendment and allow our representatives of faith to speak freely and without fear of retribution."

Proponents of the Johnson Amendment describe it as an important bulwark that shields nonprofits and houses of worship from partisan politics.

According to Brendan Fischer of the nonpartisan Campaign Legal Center, the Johnson Amendment "protects charities and churches from some of the pressures associated with partisan political activity."

"Churches and religious organizations are currently free to engage in whatever kind of speech they want," said Vandewalker. "What this is about is about spending a large amount of money."

But repealing the amendment would have far-reaching consequences beyond the pew.

The original bill introduced in the House this year limited the Johnson Amendment repeal to "churches," but the language was changed in the House Ways and Means Committee to broaden the scope of the repeal to include all 501(c)(3) nonprofits, meaning every nonprofit would be able to endorse and support candidates and causes.

"The Johnson Amendment today infringes on the First Amendment rights of nonprofit employees -- whether they work at a charity, church or community organization," a spokeswoman for Ways and Means Chairman Kevin Brady, R-Texas, said in a statement. "This bill simply protects the Constitutional rights of those employees so they can speak freely on matters affecting their communities, including making candidate-related statements."

The change would also cost billions of dollars. The non-partisan Joint Committee on Taxation estimates the rule change would cost the US treasury around $2.1 billion over the next decade in lost revenue, assuming billions of dollars of political donations would be funneled through newly tax-deductible nonprofits.

Open to manipulation?

The language of the bill includes certain restrictions on how nonprofits can participate in politics. Political activity can only be made in the organization's "regular and customary activities," and the groups can only incur "de minimis incremental expenses." "De minimis" is a legal term for "minimal and inconsequential."

But critics say both restrictions are undefined and thus open to manipulation.

"'De-minimis' is not defined, which means that you could expect political operatives to push the envelope," Fischer told CNN. "The law's claim to apply very narrowly is effectively meaningless because the terms in the law are ambiguous and we know that the IRS is not going to enforce the law against political operatives that push the envelope."

According to Fischer of the Campaign Legal Center, if the rule change becomes law "then we as taxpayers would be effectively subsidizing these secret political contributions of the handful of billionaires that tend to fund our political campaigns."

One fear is the creation of "sham" charities and churches to hide dark money and allow for donors to claim their political donations as tax-deductible.

"Given what we know about the law, we think this would open the door to tax deductible dark money," Fischer said.

Tax-exempt political donations?

One of the outcomes of the Citizens United ruling was that politically-active nonprofits, or 501(c)4 groups, could accept unlimited anonymous contributions, so called "dark money." According to the Campaign Legal Center, at least-$800 million of dark money-has been spent since the 2010 Supreme Court ruling. With the repeal of the Johnson Amendment, donors could now shift their money into tax-deductible 501(c)(3)s.

"Donors will be able to give the money in secret but would also get a tax break for doing so. So they would be encouraged by the IRS to give this secret money in politics," said Vandewalker.

Another issue at play: the corrupting of existing nonprofits and churches.

With the new rules in place, billions would likely be diverted from Super PACs into charities. And that new money could come with strings attached. Donors would be free to make donations to a charity or religious organization contingent on the group supporting a certain piece of legislation or candidate.

"Any kind of deal, explicit or handshake, could be made and the voters would never know about it simply because there's no disclosure of where the money is coming from" said Vandewalker.

Tim Delaney, the chairman of the National Council of Nonprofits, describes the rule change as an "existential" threat to nonprofits.

"For the first time in history, it would make campaign contributions tax deductible. It will completely change American politics and certainly alter forever the independence of charitable nonprofits," Delaney said.

Indiana Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Cases: 663511

Reported Deaths: 12633
CountyCasesDeaths
Marion908511647
Lake48510882
Allen35951638
Hamilton32138398
St. Joseph30096513
Elkhart25423417
Vanderburgh21283379
Tippecanoe20096203
Johnson16380360
Porter16009272
Hendricks15855300
Clark11999181
Madison11764319
Vigo11636230
Monroe10363163
Delaware9854179
LaPorte9790197
Howard9075198
Kosciusko8574111
Bartholomew7479147
Warrick7430151
Hancock7418132
Floyd7226170
Wayne6645192
Grant6437157
Boone610389
Morgan6103125
Dubois5923111
Dearborn549068
Cass545899
Marshall5432105
Henry542593
Noble510178
Jackson465167
Shelby461490
Lawrence4189113
Gibson401781
Harrison401064
Clinton396553
Montgomery388483
DeKalb386478
Miami357663
Knox357585
Whitley349837
Huntington346277
Steuben339255
Wabash332376
Putnam331159
Ripley327762
Adams323949
Jasper317043
White297452
Jefferson295474
Daviess285596
Fayette271956
Decatur271088
Greene261680
Posey261431
Wells258575
Scott251250
Clay241544
LaGrange241270
Randolph225576
Spencer218030
Jennings215744
Washington212127
Sullivan203639
Fountain201842
Starke188451
Owen182853
Fulton179337
Jay178328
Carroll176519
Perry173435
Orange171150
Rush165322
Vermillion160842
Franklin159535
Tipton146841
Parke139416
Pike127833
Blackford120727
Pulaski106744
Newton96632
Brown95139
Benton92213
Crawford91013
Martin80214
Warren75814
Switzerland7558
Union67310
Ohio53911
Unassigned0433

Ohio Coronavirus Cases

Data is updated nightly.

Cases: 972605

Reported Deaths: 16750
CountyCasesDeaths
Franklin1123671214
Cuyahoga961861832
Hamilton735721034
Montgomery47359903
Summit40384802
Butler35577505
Lucas35489685
Stark29456803
Warren22464271
Lorain22068414
Mahoning19509537
Lake18445318
Clermont18425201
Delaware16499116
Licking15022189
Fairfield14563180
Trumbull14369413
Greene13595218
Medina13423226
Clark12288248
Wood11575163
Portage11050164
Allen10793216
Richland10316183
Miami10035189
Muskingum8195112
Columbiana8151200
Pickaway8067107
Tuscarawas8054227
Marion7996125
Wayne7886193
Erie6914140
Ross6152128
Geauga6083136
Hancock6006116
Ashtabula5978152
Scioto596280
Lawrence527118
Union513537
Darke5036114
Belmont496659
Huron4825107
Jefferson4806107
Sandusky4780108
Seneca4702107
Washington465791
Athens465047
Mercer458780
Auglaize456180
Shelby441679
Knox4037101
Putnam399390
Madison393553
Fulton380658
Ashland380581
Defiance372583
Brown369844
Crawford358396
Logan355772
Preble353678
Clinton340852
Highland328349
Ottawa324369
Williams302662
Jackson290545
Champaign288149
Guernsey287844
Perry269847
Fayette269141
Morrow260334
Henry246658
Hardin245858
Holmes243293
Coshocton237454
Van Wert229854
Gallia222631
Adams217036
Pike215626
Wyandot210447
Hocking194554
Carroll181341
Paulding160530
Meigs135730
Noble129233
Monroe117027
Morgan101119
Harrison100624
Vinton76613
Unassigned00
Fort Wayne
Partly Cloudy
36° wxIcon
Hi: 42° Lo: 29°
Feels Like: 28°
Angola
Mostly Cloudy
32° wxIcon
Hi: 39° Lo: 27°
Feels Like: 24°
Huntington
Partly Cloudy
36° wxIcon
Hi: 42° Lo: 28°
Feels Like: 29°
Fort Wayne
Partly Cloudy
36° wxIcon
Hi: 42° Lo: 29°
Feels Like: 28°
Lima
Cloudy
31° wxIcon
Hi: 42° Lo: 28°
Feels Like: 21°
Sunny, Cooler Thursday
WFFT Radar
WFFT Temperatures
WFFT National

Community Events